AI tools fail to reduce recruitment bias – study – BBC

Artificially intelligent hiring tools do not reduce bias or improve diversity, researchers say in a study.
"There is growing interest in new ways of solving problems such as interview bias," the Cambridge University researchers say, in the journal Philosophy and Technology
The use of AI is becoming widespread – but its analysis of candidate videos or applications is "pseudoscience".
A professional body for human resources told BBC News AI could counter bias.
In 2020, the study notes, an international survey of 500 human-resources professionals suggested nearly a quarter were using AI for "talent acquisition, in the form of automation".
But using it to reduce bias is counter-productive and, University of Cambridge's Centre for Gender Studies post-doctoral researcher Dr Kerry Mackereth told BBC News, based on "a myth".
"These tools can't be trained to only identify job-related characteristics and strip out gender and race from the hiring process, because the kinds of attributes we think are essential for being a good employee are inherently bound up with gender and race," she said.
Some companies have also found these tools problematic, the study notes.
In 2018, for example, Amazon announced it had scrapped the development of an AI-powered recruitment engine because it could detect gender from CVs and discriminated against female applicants.
Of particular concern to the researchers were tools to "analyse the minutiae of a candidate's speech and bodily movements" to see how closely they resembled a company's supposed ideal employee.
Video and image analysis technology had "no scientific basis", co-author Dr Eleanor Drage told BBC News, dismissing it as "modern phrenology", the false theory skull shape could reveal character and mental faculties.
"They say that they can know your personality from looking at your face. The idea is that, like a lie-detector test, AI can see 'through' your face to the real you," she told BBC News.
With six computer-science students, the researchers built their own simplified AI recruitment tool, to rate candidates' photographs for the "big five" personality traits:
But the ratings were skewed by many irrelevant variables.
"When you use our tool, you can see that your personality score changes when you alter the contrast/brightness/saturation," Dr Drage wrote.
Technology news site The Register noted other investigations had reached a similar conclusion.
A German public broadcaster found wearing glasses or a headscarf in a video changed a candidate's scores.
Hayfa Mohdzaini, from the Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development, told BBC News its research suggested only 8% of employers used AI to select candidates.
"AI can efficiently help increase an organisation's diversity by filtering from a larger candidate pool – but it can also miss out on lots of good candidates if the rules and training data are incomplete or inaccurate," she said.
"AI software to analyse candidates' voice and body language in recruitment is in its infancy and therefore carries both opportunities and risks."
The computers rejecting your job application
Amazon scrapped 'sexist AI' tool
Biden and Trump in last-ditch bid for crucial midterms votes
Fisherman tried to break window to save pilots
We are on highway to climate hell, UN chief warns summit
What Trump is hoping for on election night
How US voters get shown hate online
Looking for clues in video of forgotten massacre. Video
The election deniers who could control the 2024 vote
The agony of not knowing, as Mariupol mass burial sites grow
Twitter users jump to Mastodon – but what is it?
The big issues facing Egypt's COP27 climate summit
The surprising truth about the Philistines
South Koreans demand justice for Itaewon dead
The young US men choosing vasectomies
Istanbul's beloved 'brothel dessert'
The world's greatest unpaid debt?
© 2022 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read about our approach to external linking.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Lakers sign Thomas Bryant Tom Brady hint at unretirement this year Kevin Durant trade Warriors stars Brooklyn Nets to sign T.J. Warren ‘Minions’ Fire With $110.5 Million debut